
Hitchcock, BIP, 1930, from Clemence Dane and Helen Simpson's Enter Sir John. A jury convicts an actress (Norah Baring). One juror, actor-manager Sir John (Herbert Marshall), is not sure and starts over. BFI notes what some call an early use of voice-over as thought: Marshall shaving while a phonograph of his own voice plays and a live orchestra does Wagner off-set, because you could not post-dub yet. The case ends at a circus. Alma Reville is on the scenario credit.
A juror who is an actor decides to start the case over. Marshall shaving while a phonograph plays his own thoughts and an orchestra does Wagner off-set, because you could not post-dub yet. The case ends at a circus. Alma Reville on the scenario. By now he can do both kinds of film.